When training a new dog, I reward every time at source. This builds the reliability of proper detection.
When the dog becomes reliable and is performing their trained alert at source effectively, then I start to change it up to see what the dog will do.
Jesea is at a point where I will sometimes find two hides before the tug is produced. She gets a "Good Girl, nice Fish (her command is "Go Fish"), there's more" and she will continue on to find the next hide. I then reward at that source......
I want a dog that does not anticipate me, once they start doing that, then they are going to throw the alert falsley to see if they can get what they want.
Has Jesea ever false alerted???? You bet....Have I ever rewarded on a false alert???? When I was learning back when she was about 10 months old, yes I did.
Is it in my training records???? YOU BET!!!! Everything I do with the dog is logged. Her video footage is also logged as training records with mistakes and without. I do not omit anything from records. If she takes a dump, standing on her head while working, that gets written down.
I see so many people and work with so many people that do the same thing over and over and over and then ask, "Why is my dog so far behind? Why will she only work when I do this?" and it is because they have conditioned the dog that working only happens in this sequence and if the sequence is broken the dog has a WTF? moment and won't work.
Therefore, I am religious about how my training program works.
I make sure the dog understands the job and then throw out all kinds of REALISTIC scenarios and exercises so that my dog learns to work no matter what is going on.
Some people do not train that way and that is great, if their dog works reliably and training logs show that over 70 to 85% of the time their dog is nailing it, then I do not have a problem with others training methods.
No dog is ever going to be 100% correct every time. I have seen others logs that show that and it is usually because they do not understand the training log concept and once they are taught correctly then their logs change to reflect where their strong and weak points are. This gives them areas in their training that they need to work on. That is what the logs are for.
Some people think that their dog is the "OMNI" dog and never makes a mistake. Not on my watch, no way, no how.....dogs mess up, handlers mess up and you will get eaten alive in court if you try to hide or ignore that fact.
This next part is just a comment not directed at anyone in particular:
People try and pick me apart all the time and that is fine. I am totally confident in my work, training habits and logs AND my dogs work....period. If I get a dog that is haphazard and only works part of the time, I wash it. I have no use for half-assed dogs.
However, I learn from this also, they may actually see something I am doing wrong, that's great. Another tool for the tool bag.
Until The Tale of the Lioness is told, the Story will Always Glorfy the Hunter