Did the pup have anything to do with that one miss?
It's great that the pup is responding at the same time but don't let it become to much of a distraction.
Do you put the dog on a sit, leave it then call?
Don't fall into a pattern by calling the dog from the same position every time. Sometimes a sit, sometimes a down, sometimes loosed walking and just as often return to the dog without a recall.
The dog will figure out a pattern much faster then you realize your making one.
No, that particular miss was without the Sugar the puppy.
I am almost never calling Trooper from a sit, especially out front in public, but rather from various "doggie activities", sniffing, looking down the street, walking the perimeter, after I call stop at the end of the lead, or rolling with the puppy WHEN she is out there too.
(I am making sure to take each of them out separately AND together. It's kiling my bad hip but my motivation is high.)
There are almost certainly some patterns in there, just from the fact that Trooper does a finite number of things.
If anything the puppy MAY be helping me get him back -- he loves to play with her but once I call him he tries to AVOID letting her get the play going again so while he might walk off line to get around her, he tends to hurry back to me to avoid her.
It's amazing how much time I put into this in the past doing fairly "good" clicker training but how much faster is my progress after watching the first portions of quite a few of Michael's videos.
(I am not "skipping around", but rather working through each video until I get to an area that will take time but then also looking at other videos up to a similar point.)
Right now I am working alone since my wife is out of town, but coming home tomorrow.
Sugar the puppy is doing pretty well at recalls. Typically, I only get 'away from her' a few times before she starts following me around so I just switch to getting her to pay attention to me while she walks along side.
TODAY: When I had Trooper out today alone, doing recalls, I was getting tired and my hip was hurting so, when he came to me, we just went through "some of his favorite behaviors" as someone in this (or another) thread suggested.
While, I have gotten Trooper to sometimes sit or lie down while out in public, or occasionally to take a treat without spitting it back out, he was TAKING THE TREATS and PAYING ATTENTION so we were connected.
This is HUGE for us.
He's a good dog, and while I am not claiming any great training skill I do ALRIGHT for teaching in any condition where that connection is present.
He did a couple of things that I never really ask him to do in public -- SPIN (clockwise) and WHIRL (counter clockwise) but the most fun was something he has NEVER DONE IN PUBLIC:
Inside he does a great "Dead Dog" when you pretend to shoot him, so I gave him the signal and "Bang" and he did his best and most dramatic 'dying', complete with last gasp and tail flop. (It's hard to get a Golden to EVER stop wagging his tail.)
Now this is just a 'fun trick' but it represents a new level of connection.
People here (along with Michael's videos) are HUGELY RESPONSIBLE for helping us to achieve this so....
THANK YOU ALL!