Dear Folks --

I am seriously considering a different breed dog. I've had GSD for over 10 years, and yes they are addictive -- but I may not have chosen the "Right Breed" for my needs. This occured to me when I found the GSD's I liked best were not the "type" favored by the mainstream of GSD people.

My +ONLY+ concerns with changing breeds are, Temperment, Ability, Temperment and ABILITY (did I say Intelligence?)

It's also significant that we're economicly challenged, so anything with Blue-Dollarz Bloodlines is completely out of reach.

The good news is I have no interest whatsoever in the dog's appearance, so long as it's size is sufficient to effectively manage a determined "space invader" (my current dogs primary purpose is bodyguard for my son and self)

In fact, I would prefer a dog that does NOT appear to be a "Stereo-Type Guard Dog", but rather appears to be "Just a big Pooch". The reason is to NOT intimidate neighbors/postmen and other folks (nor invite poisoning from same)

In addition to being highly intelligent ("thinks for her/himself and might be able to read"), having a NATURAL guarding instinct,
I need a dog with an "Inborn" SOLID, willing, reliable recall. I have no interest in showing, trialing, or any of that, though do plan to invest alot of time training (I just like training and dogs peoples <g>

Any suggestions?

Bobbie C.

-newb opinion-

I think American Bulldogs and Airedales are worth consideration. Good, solid dogs with intelligence, stable temperaments, and abilities.


Andy.

American Bull Dogs are more than capable of protection, how ever they need a good pack leader, some one who is consistant and sure in there actions and expectations, a person they respect. If not they COULD be the bite of meat you choke on....I have respect for the breed. Lance

Might want to look at working line Giant Schnauzers also.

What "type" is favored by the mainstream of gsd people?

GSD

Not to sound like a negative Nancy, but I trained an Airedale to a SchH II back in the 80's - I could have trained *four* GSD's or Mal's to an equivalent title in the same amount of time!

Anatolian Shepherd.