*Sigh*
Ok, I'll guess I'll have to close this one also, due to increasing personal attacks.

Howard, please don't call people 'retards" - it's uncalled for. Make your points with logic and experience to back it up, and you won't get so many negative comments. Alot of people are posting wishful thinking or unrealistic behavior expectations about canines, and these threads get real off topic fast.
And posting the continual mis-adventures of your dog is bringing people out of the woodwork with comments on your dog's temperment, and your handling of such. If you post this kind of info, you'll have to expect some bad comments out of it, along with some helpful ( and un-helpful ) advice. I get that all the time when I post about my dog. <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif" alt="" />

But I understand your frustration with people that have no knowledge or experience with PPD's ( or really, aggressive dogs, period ) commenting on the same, when the thread took that direction.

And Roger,
I missed anyone calling themselves an "expert" in any of these threads. But I think the level of posters here varies widely - which means that people with zero experience, and very little knowledge can post on topics repeatedly and try to push forward ideas that just have no basis in reality.
And Ed is constantly adding, changing, or correcting his articles all the time. I don't think that anyone is required to agree with Ed 100% on every topic ( although I agree with most of what he says )