For 40+ years we've helped over 300,000 dog trainers just like you!

Learn more about Leerburg

$6.99 Flat Rate Shipping

Learn more
Ask Cindy Our Newsletter Free Catalog
Leerburg » Leerburg Q&A » Answered

Do you have a dog training or equipment question?
Leerburg's Q&A database has 3354 entries from multiple categories.


Categories: Behavioral Problems

Q. Our GSD has always barked when he hears noises outside but now when he hears something he quickly goes after our other dog as if she were the threat. How can I get him to stop associating our other dog with noises he hears outside?
Hi Cindy! Thanks so much for all the helpful info you've shared.

We have a 2.5-year-old male GSD who has always been a major barker when he hears someone outside our house – especially other dogs. We and our trainer have been trying to train him out of it and thought we were seeing progress up until recently. He developed a scary habit where upon hearing someone outside, he not only barks but quickly goes after our other dog (a 3-year-old malinois) as if she were the threat, even if she is several feet away from him. This only happens in the house.

It hasn't resulted in any actual bites or bloodshed, but he certainly charges her and I'm sure things would escalate if we didn't intervene.

How can I get him to stop associating our other dog with noises he hears outside?

They are in separate kennels when unsupervised and we're keeping him leashed in the house at all other times. He also wears an Educator e-collar, but so far using it when this happens seems to escalate his reaction.

A. Some dogs are just this way, they become over stimulated and will channel their excitement/aggression into who ever is close by (dog or human).

If this was my dog he would not be allowed the opportunity to redirect into the other dog and I would do as you have been and keep him leashed 100% of the time when he's not kenneled. Have you used a no bark collar for him when he's kenneled so he's corrected anytime he barks (while being safely confined so he can't redirect)?

How long have you been working with the trainer and what techniques have you been trying? If he's always been a major barker it may be a lifelong exercise in management and you may never be able to completely stop this behavior without direct supervision.


Cindy, thank you so much for the quick and thoughtful reply! I intended to respond immediately but am jumping back in much later than I meant to. This dog has been working with our trainer since early puppyhood, even before being rehomed with us (born into an animal hoarding situation, unbeknownst to the trainer) and the barking will definitely be a lifelong exercise in management — but the tips in Tyler Muto's "Leash Reactivity" video have proven to be a HUGE help with his reacitvity inside the house as well as on the sidewalk.

Honestly, I can't thank you all enough for the difference that video has made. His exercises have helped us keep Xorro (the reactive/redirecting GSD) focused on us rather than our other dog, and his stress level has decreased significantly. Since we were keeping him him on-leash inside the house anyway, we started applying Tyler's leash pressure, "place," and "look" exercises as if Xorro was encountering another dog on the sidewalk. He still barks when he hears another dog outside our house, but he's noticeably less stressed out about it – and redirecting towards our other dog FAR less!

We'll keep working on it and keep you posted. Thank you for the immeasurable help you provide!
Recommended Products
Establishing Pack Structure with the Family Pet
Establishing Pack Structure with the Family Pet
4 Hours
The goal of our pack structure training program is to produce a dog that is calm and submissive and a dog that follows the rules of the pack leader. This DVD teaches people how to become a pack leader that their dog respects and loves. Most people are not born pack leaders. In fact, far from it. The majority of dog owners (many who have owned dogs their entire life) simply do not know anything about the instincts that control our dogs or how strong these instincts are in the domestic dog. Oh people may have heard that they need to be a pack leader or they may have heard they need to be an ALPHA with their dog but they do not understand what this really means or how to accomplish it.

Basic Dog Obedience DVD
Basic Dog Obedience DVD
4 Hours
This DVD is 4 hours long. The purpose of this Leerburg training DVD is teach you the art of dog training. It's our goal to show you that dog training is not rocket science it's 100% common sense. There are no "Tricks or Secrets of the Trade." Dog training is an art that you can learn if you're willing to put your mind to it. The best dog trainers know how to build a bond based on two way respect between the dog and the handler. These trainers know how to motivate a dog to want to learn. They understand how and when to apply distractions during training so they can show the dog that it must mind under all circumstances.


20% off Select Michael Ellis DVDs, streams, and courses good through Thursday, July 23, 2020 at 11:59 PM CT