For 40+ years we've helped over 300,000 dog trainers just like you!

Learn more about Leerburg

$6.99 Flat Rate Shipping

Learn more
Ask Cindy Our Newsletter Free Catalog
Leerburg » Leerburg Q&A » Answered

Do you have a dog training or equipment question?
Leerburg's Q&A database has 3353 entries from multiple categories.


Categories: Puppy Training

Q. I took my puppy to a group class and I had a hard time getting her attention. At what point should I practice obedience in a group setting?
Hi Cindy,

Training question for the GSD puppy: I never ask her to do anything she cannot do, however, our trainer felt it would be good for her to do basic obedience in the class with 3 other puppies. We failed miserably. She was focused on the other puppies. I had a really hard time getting her attention with treats and tug. Am I wrong to think that we should stay away from group classes now or should we participate even if it means a whole lot of corrections with the prong? Also, at what point should we start to practice obedience in the group setting? I'm guessing when I can get her focused despite dog distractions during our walks -
right, wrong, sideways?


A. I don't use group classes for puppies EXCEPT for working my engagement. And I would not take a puppy to a group class of other puppies. I have taken my pups to an advanced obedience class where all the dogs are focused on their handlers and not looking at me or my pup. I then simply go off to the side and work my engagement with food or toys. I may have to go VERY far away at first, in order to keep my puppy interested in me and I don't actually work on behaviors. Just engagement and food games.


Makes sense - thank you!

On the side note (and I meant to email this to you a while back): I also wanted to thank you and Ed for the website. In truth, the information on your site is the very reason we finally decided that we are educated enough to handle a relatively high drive GSD puppy. There has been many moments where we simply went on “blind faith” that you guys know best and we need to follow the guidance in your articles and videos. The results (not just the puppy, but me as a handler) have been nothing short of amazing. I also wanted to mention that we buy equipment from your store – the fact that product descriptions very clearly state which ones are right for each phase of puppy/dog development has been extremely helpful. We no longer shop at other venues because it turns into guesswork and then wasted money and time.

So thank a bunch!

  Follow-Up Response:

Thank you so much for this. It makes my day!

I think you have good instincts about what's right for your puppy but when you have a question you can always write to me. Have a great day!
Recommended Products
Your Puppy 8 Weeks to 12 Months
Your Puppy 8 Weeks to 12 Months
Your Puppy 8 Weeks to 12 Months is a 3 hour DVD that teaches pet owners how to raise a puppy they can live with.

Living with Your Puppy: Establishing Pack Structure
Living with Your Puppy: Establishing Pack Structure
Every new puppy owner has the same image of what they want their new dog to be like as an adult. First and foremost, everyone wants a great relationship with their dog but beyond that, those who plan on keeping their dog in their home want a calm, well-mannered, obedient house dog that minds and respects their family and friends. Those who plan on keeping their dog outside want a calm well mannered dog that is respectful to the family and is quiet in the yard or kennel. They only want their dog to bark at strangers that come near the home. New dog owners think the road to success only involves obedience training and house training new puppies. Well that is the old wives tale that is been spread for 100 years and nothing could be further from the truth.


$25 off Michael Ellis 3 Day Workshop and Raising Your Puppy with Michael Ellis, and $15 off The Foundation of Puppy Bitework with Michael Ellis, good through Thursday, August 6, 2020 at 11:59 PM CT