May 17, 2011

I take my dog to obedience classes and our trainer tells us to use only Halties and not prong collars. I can't control my dog when we go for walks. What can I do?

Full Question:
Mr. Frawley,

I recently came across your site and have spent all morning reading your advice on training dogs with behavioral problems. I'm hoping you can take a moment to give me some 1-on-1 training. I have a 2-year old Smooth Collie who has been in obedience training since he was 12 weeks old. The obedience center we attend strongly encourages use of a Gentle Leader while training, and equally as strongly discourages the use of prong or shock collars. My problem is this: When we're out for a walk, the dog becomes uncontrollable if a bicyclist rides by us. He lunges toward the cyclist, hair standing on end, barking and whimpering. I've tried several different methods to regain control in these instances including diverting his attention by walking in the opposite direction, trying to get his attention with "high reward" treats and trying to be dominant over him by sitting him and standing between him and the path of the cyclist. I've also tried desensitization methods which work to an extent-especially if the biker/rollerblader is across the street or at some distance away. The problem is worst when there's an element of surprise like when the biker comes up from behind us or passes right in front of us. I'm well aware that I'm failing as an owner to control this behavior, but I don't know what other methods to try. I've recently considered using a shock collar on him, but he's a very sensitive dog (as collies can be) so I'm a bit leery about it. Can you please tell me if I should continue working with the desensitization method or if it's time to try something else?

Thank you
Ed
Ed Ed's Answer:
The first thing you should do is discontinue doing business with this foolish obedience trainer you have been working with. Their position shows a complete lack of understanding on the principles of good dog training.

I shake my head at trainers who pass out this halty information and tell new pet owners not to use prong collars or training collars. There are only three kinds of training collars:
  1. a flat collar (leather or nylon)
  2. a prong collar
  3. an electric collar
I don’t have time to educate you through email - my web site is about 5,000 pages and my web discussion board has 6,600 registered members - its very active.

If you want to learn the correct way to obedience train your dog you should get a prong collar and my 4 hour DVD on Basic Dog Obedience.

63% (17 out of 27)
respondents found this answer helpful
Did you find this Q&A helpful?
Expert Dog Trainer Cindy Rhodes
63% (17 out of 27)
respondents found this answer helpful

Did you find this Q&A helpful?

Recommended Products
Scroll to Top