Can I give my puppy (who is learning marker training) a treat at an odd time without saying YES? In other words, Does she have to hear the word YES come out of my mouth before she receives a treat?

Hi Cindy,

I'm training my 12 week old F Malinois using marker training and it's working great. I've purchased the bait bag from you that I have clipped on at all times. I'm doing a ton of engagement with her (eye contact) and she's focusing on me for up to 5 seconds before I say "YES," pause, and reward her with food (hotdogs) or a toy reward. I haven't began incorporating any commands, but that's just around the corner.

My question is: Can I give my puppy (who is learning marker training) a treat the odd time without saying "YES"? In other words, Does she have to hear the word "YES" come out of my mouth before she receives a treat?

I'll give you an example: When she's comfortably relaxing in front of the fireplace, and I don't want her to move, I want to praise her state of mind in that moment she's relaxed. So can I approach her and say 'good relax' and give her a treat. Or just give it to her without saying anything?

Please advise.

Thanks.