March 22, 2011

Should I neuter my puppy?

Full Question:
I've read Leerburg's info and all the threads on Neutering. And tons of other material, experiences, etc. I've gone through this 7 years ago with my Adult. But the more I read the less convincing the messages are on either side.

Do you think the Puppy's behavior (dominance) can be controlled by continuing to be a Leader? Or for ultimate security because both dogs are involved should the Puppy be neutered? If it was my decision straight-up I don't want to do it... but I don't want to miss my window of opportunity if it's the better thing to do!

Thank you,
Kelley
Cindy
Cindy Cindy's Answer:
As you found out with your older dog, neutering doesn’t change a dominant personality.

I won’t ever neuter a dog until he’s physically and mentally mature.

Sorry, this has to be your decision.

Cindy Rhodes
User Response:
I'm the only one who can make the decision so I am not looking for a "do it" or "don't" response. But comments regarding #1 and #2 will help me to be sure. I also understand the preference is to keep working dogs intact.

1) Given the puppy is tending towards dominance, setting aside health concerns and indescriminate breeding prevention - do you think people assume a neutered dog will be easier to "handle" instead of using solid training (like Leerburg) instead?

2) "Breeders" tell me IF I neuter the puppy while he's still a puppy he'll stay "sweet and gentle." It was said my Adult dog didn't change because I waited too long to neuter the Adult at 4 years. But I've also read, just like you said, a dog should be structurally mature. Can you see why this issue is Sooooo confusing?

I know you're very busy....and appreciate your time! I won't keep "bugging" you after this....

Thx
Cindy
Cindy Cindy's Answer:
A dog’s temperament and dominance are part of his personality.

People do assume a neutered dog will be easier to handle, but I don’t agree. It’s training and leadership.

I get MANY emails every day from people w/ aggression problems and the vast majority of them are neutered/spayed.

Vets love to push neutering as a solution to behavioral issues and it’s just not the case. It can play a role, but a dominant/aggressive dog is going to be that way whether he’s neutered or not if he isn’t trained. There is no substitute for training.

I don’t believe in removing a dog’s body parts to try to manipulate his personality.

Cindy Rhodes

100% (5 out of 5)
respondents found this answer helpful
Did you find this Q&A helpful?
Expert Dog Trainer Cindy Rhodes
100% (5 out of 5)
respondents found this answer helpful

Did you find this Q&A helpful?

Recommended Products
Scroll to Top